Kill Your Darlings
My blog died.
I tried in vain to save it. Friends kindly came to its rescue, and for a while, it seemed like my little blog just…might…make it. I watched fire slowly creep back back into its eyes and, oh, how I began to hope! But, alas, in the end, neither my friends, network, nor myself could save it. WhatMovesYou.tumblr.com just didn’t have the strength to survive on its own, and I had to accept the sad, sad truth: some ideas really should die.
Painful as that reality was, I have Adaptive Path to thank for teaching me how to gracefully let go. My first introduction to this zen-like state was via an unexpected phrase: “Kill your darlings”. The first time I heard those words at work, I was astounded that such brutality could be thrown around so casually amongst my coworkers. I shrank back in horror, wondering what kind of people I was working with. But, slowly, project by project, client by client, I began to understand that there are a plethora of good reasons to kill off a perfectly good idea. In fact, here are actual reasons my colleague have killed off their own darlings:
- It just didn’t fit. Awesome idea—wrong project.
- It was evil, preying up bad human tendencies.
- No one really needed it; it was a manufactured need.
- The good idea was only good to me.
- Someone had a better idea.
- Good idea, already been done by the competition. (Parity is not a strategy)
- It was not technically possible/easy.
- It would piss off a partner/customer/supplier.
- It was too expensive.
- When you only have time for 10 great ideas, the 11th goes.
- It did not actually serve the mission of the organization or needs of the user.
- It was just cool.
- It was a GREAT idea…in a vacuum.
- The client wasn’t ready for it (or the market or customers).
- It couldn’t be done to the level it should be to be successful or match our vision.
- I needed to let it go to allow it to evolve.
Every project has restraints and realities that can’t be ignored, no matter how much you want to pursue a particularly brilliant concept. To help mitigate that, it’s important to trust that there are always plenty of creative ideas where the last one came from. Otherwise, you’re working within a belief system of limits, which is certain to undermine creativity.
My favorite motto encapsulating this concept comes for a podcast I did with writer and public speaker, Scott Berkun: Don’t be so precious. The gist of our conversation was about taking risks with your own work by focusing on generation of ideas, rather than holding tight to one. “Don’t be so precious” is a phrase I repeat to myself often, particularly when I’m feeling stuck or attached, and it has helped me get out of many a creative jam.
So, in honor of all the awesome ideas that have died before, will die soon, or really should die, I’m having a funeral for my dead blog. It begins now, via this post, and you’re all invited to join me by submitting a comment in honor of a great idea you willingly killed off.
There are 6 comments on this idea.
Thanks for giving a memorable mantra to a frequent phenomenon! I write for a living and for fun, and it took me years to learn and kill darling precious sentences as soon as I’ve written them.
My college papers are full of them, and they pop up in my early professional work. Now it’s enough to write them done, realize they ARE useless, ill-fitting and precious - and delete them right away.
Thanks for the feedback, Kai. When you get more comfortable killing your darlings, it certainly is liberating. And it’s validating when you look back and realize that many weren’t necessarily all that darling!
Glad you enjoyed the post.
It is true!! I am a grad student at Indiana University, HCID program. I still remember going through that horror feeling, when my professor forced us to shred our sketched ideas, well deep into our project to come up with new ones. But now when I think about it, I feel energized when someone doesnt like my idea or challenges it, I am able to come up with different ones. But, these ones sometimes base off of those killed ideas. Then, yes, I realize those werent that darling-of-an-idea at all.
The guys over at Behance have a nice article on sending ideas to the graveyard.
http://the99percent.com/tips/5731/send-ideas-to-the-graveyard
Sending ideas to the graveyard is part of my process.
I can’t agree more.
And I think this is why prototyping is being recognized as one of the key design activities.
I had a change to discuss this over a workshop about innovation at Stanford Media X. Here’s a link to the supporting slides:
http://slidesha.re/cNQ2BR
Add to the conversation.
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.