home > services 

Adaptive Path Blog

The Team

Alexa

Smart.fm: Why Goals are the new Lists

by Alexa

Part of the Smart.fm iPhone App Story

While Dan is busy coding away at the iPhone App, I wanted take this time to share about our first project with smart.fm, a project to reimagine the smart.fm web experience!

smart.fm Case Study Header

What’s in a name? What we call something can have a profound impact on the way we think about it. And changing the way we think about something can have powerful implications on what we design and how we evaluate it. For smart.fm, the ah-ha moment came when we realized that it’s about Goals, not Lists.

Smart.fm is a learning community founded on a powerful technology that equips users to memorize anything — from the Capitals of the World to Japanese Vocabulary to the names of various Heart Murmurs. Today, you learn using Lists. A List is a set of content about a topic that is typically managed by a single person or a content partner. While Lists are a straightforward organizing principle, they don’t form natural hubs of activity. It’s hard to rally around a list.

Smart.fm partnered with Adaptive Path to transform the site into a “motivating, social world of learning.” Collaborating closely with smart.fm, our team (Me, Brian Cronin and Kate Rutter) sought out new ways to bring people together and engage them in collaboration and competition around learning. Through a series of exercises where we envisioned what the experience of using smart.fm could be like, the answer that emerged was Goals.

Instead of organizing content around topics, which people may study for many different reasons, content will soon be organized around Goals that people can form communities around. But before I get into the exciting implications of this shift, I wanted to share some of the experience-minded tools that led us to it:

1) We described the experience we wanted to aim for.

Using our Elevator Pitch “mad-lib” template, we brainstormed ways to fill in the blanks: “For people who… the new smart.fm is… It’s different because…” Ideas that emerged included “Smart.fm is like a pickup basketball game — it’s easy to jump right in and participate.” We refined these ideas into guiding principles that described the ideal smart.fm experience: “a friendly social world of learning” that “invites play” and “reveals and celebrates progress.”

2) We dissected the experience and brainstormed new metaphors for its parts.

From the experience mapping and metaphor brainstorming exercises that I wrote about previously, we selected some of the most compelling metaphors.

3) We imagined some possible experiences inspired by these metaphors.

We then explored how they could be applied to the major activities of the smart.fm experience — discovering, learning, celebrating, collecting, making and collaborating — and communicated the resulting ideas through “Concept Posters.” These posters enabled us to describe what an experience should feel like without getting into interface details. Aspects of the poster showing how “Smart.fm is like a scavenger hunt for knowledge” particularly stood out to the team — especially the idea of challenging users to create content through collaborative scavenger hunts.

4) We pictured the future.

We then used sketches of “The Homepage of the Future” to explore the best concepts further. Since a well-designed homepage tells the story of what you’re all about, sketching potential homepages can be a great way to boil a concept down to its essence using a value proposition, some featured content, and a presentation of core features or “how it works.”

5) It all came together in “Goal-Based Missions” — or simply, Goals

These explorations culminated in the idea of “Missions,” which we articulated through sketchy diagrams illustrating an exciting, game-like smart.fm where social activity is embedded into everything.

As the new activity hubs, Missions brought both learning material and social activity together in an elegant and cohesive way:

  • Missions are about shared goals. While people may learn English for many reasons, people who want to “Spend a Week in the US,” “Impress their friends” or “Pass the TOEFL” will have much more in common with each other than everyone learning “English Vocabulary I.”
  • Missions are social by nature. The shared goal is what brings people together. Instead of “signing up” or “enrolling,” you can “Join” or “Participate” in a Mission, competing or collaborating with other team members who share the same goal.
  • Missions can be about creating content, not just learning it. The scavenger hunts idea from the concept posters manifested itself in the “Fact-Finding” aspect of Missions: If you want to learn enough Japanese for a week in Japan, but don’t know enough to build a list of stuff to learn — you can challenge others to create content for you.

While my high school sister loved the idea of “24-like” Missions, proposing there be “Objectives” and “Directors” and spy tools, the idea of collaborative Missions lives on under the more neutral name, “Goals.” Since the final wireframes were delivered, Smart.fm has already enabled collaborative list-building, and soon you’ll be able to do much more, including:

  • Collaborate with others who share a goal (say, “Become culturally literate”) to create and collect learning material that will help you achieve it.
  • Challenge other users to contribute content about a certain topic (such as “Hip Hop Artists” or “Internet Memes” — you can actually add content to these lists today!).
  • Ask questions about things you want to learn (“How do you say ‘Experience Design’ in Japanese?”) and get answers from others.
  • Earn badges for completing your goals and responding to challenges.
  • See how you’re doing compared to others who are pursuing the same goal, others in your hometown, and perhaps even others who share your first name!

These are just a few of the exciting possibilities that reframing Lists as Goals has afforded, and we look forward to seeing both the name change and mindset change taking shape on smart.fm!

9 Responses to “Smart.fm: Why Goals are the new Lists”

  1. Paul May Says:

    This is really interesting Alexa. During the project, did you work with SmartFM users (or other members of the public) to validate the concepts you came up with during workshops? Sometimes I/we fall into the habit of constructing metaphors and ideas around our idealised picture of people using a service we’re building – I was wondering what you did to balance this out with how people *actually* behave. Thanks for the great post.

    Paul

  2. Brbob Says:

    This is interesting stuff! Isn’t there concern about giving away all this great design information (this and the other posts) to smart.fm’s competitors though??

  3. OsandiSAYs Says:

    Greetings,

    Often we list goals but rarely are they turned into metaphors which makes them contextually a subject vs. and object | subjective vs. objective | meaningful vs. tasks.

    I’m really get into this like big TIME! Thank you for sharing.

    :}(o|O){:

  4. hoshigo Says:

    wow, this is really exciting!
    I did think at first that smart.fm limited the social aspect a bit, which I justified by saying that it has different goals (oh there’s the word) with facebook and is totally focused on what the site brings to the learning experience. Can’t wait for this next development! God bless your efforts! (^_^)

  5. John Says:

    Really interesting stuff! I used Smart.fm a while ago and was only mildly impressed, but largely for the issues you guys worked hard to overcome. I will definitely give Smart.fm another try after reading your account.

  6. Jon Says:

    This is interesting and all, but what is the timeframe for this app being released? The reason I ask is that there already an unofficial app out there http://itunes.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewSoftware?id=317036413&mt=8

    I’m not interested in waiting a year if that is what it’ll take, but I’ll happily wait a couple months to see how the official app stacks up against the unofficial one.

  7. netten.ro Says:

    Super Tareeeeeee!!!!!!! :) )))

  8. The Relaunch of Smart.fm – Smart.fm Blog Says:

    [...] a deep dive into the history of our thinking on this topic, please read the in-depth post by Alexa from Adaptive Path more about [...]

  9. licitatii Says:

    Have you ever considered adding more videos to your blog posts to keep the readers more entertained? I mean I just read through the entire article of yours and it was quite good but since I’m more of a visual learner,I found that to be more helpful.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


Where do great ideas come from?

At Adaptive Path, our ideas are driven by the work we do. We do consulting for user interface and user experience design, and offer conferences, training and education for UX designers.

From field ethnography, UI wireframes and task flows, to visual design and implementation, we do it and we teach it.

Learn more in our video, Adaptive Path in 2 ½ Minutes:

ap-video

Want to know more about Adaptive Path? You should read more about our services or contact us to find out how we can help you!

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive essays, appearance dates and other news from Adaptive Path.