Who doesn’t love book lists?
by petermeI was asked to write up a list of favorite design-related books for the newsletter site Freepint. I have no idea when such a thing would be published, and I realized it was ideally suited to the AP Blog. Enjoy! (These are *personal* choices and don’t reflect the views of Adaptive Path blah blah… and add your favorites to the comments…)
The Design of Everyday Things, Donald Norman. It’s almost hoary to mention it, but it’s one of the few books that changed my life. I’ve written more about it here
Understanding Comics, Scott McCloud. A brilliant long-form essay on the nature of creativity, how humans process visual information, and the power of narrative.
Designing for People, Henry Dreyfuss. Written over 50 years old by America’s pre-eminent industrial designer, it lays out a user-centered design philosophy long before the phrase “user-centered design” entered our professional language. Refreshing clear, straightforward, and free of the BS that clouds much design writing.
The Visual Display of Quantitative Information and Envisioning Information, Edward Tufte. These two are required reading for any one involved in communicating visually. (His later two you can pass on.)
Who Built America?, The American Social History Project. This CD-ROM, based on a textbook, set the standard for what a multimedia digital book should be. Developed in 1993, it’s marriage of text, sound, imagery, and, video, along with it’s engagement with archival sources, still inspires.
The Architecture of Happiness, Alain de Botton. The most recent book on the list, but definitely worth inclusion. A delightful book-length essay on the power that architecture has on our emotional state, fabulously illustrated with perfectly-selected photos.
How Buildings Learn, Stewart Brand. This is one of those books that every IA has read, even though it has nothing to do with IA. Stewart looks at how buildings evolve over time, and his book serves as a reminder that all of us are creating things that people are going to *use*.
Information Architecture for the World Wide Web, 2nd Edition, Lou Rosenfeld and Peter Morville. Still the best “web design” book out there, with a strong focus on what it actually takes to build great sites. And I’m not saying this just because I was a technical editor.
Interface Culture, Steven Johnson. Getting a little long in the tooth, but Johnson’s book is the first extended piece of critical writing on the subject of interface and interaction design from the viewpoint of a non-designer. Valuable in recognizing how interface engage with the culture that creates them.
The Cluetrain Manifesto (multiple authors). Written in the midst of Web 1.0, this tract on what it means for businesses to meaningfully engage in business online contains deep truths that still frighten most organizations.
Design Research, edited by Brenda Laurel. About half to two-thirds of this isn’t all that valuable, but the remainder of the book more than makes up for it. Brenda probes the boundaries of research, which is essential as we design for an increasingly uncertain world.
Shaping Things, Bruce Sterling. What happens when everything is, well, information? Bruce delves into the subject of spimes and reorients your view of things in the world. And, hey, I even dug the (oft-criticized) graphic design.
And heck, why just books? Why not also, The Films of Charles and Ray Eames? So good. So insightful.
(And, of course, there are the books written by my colleagues… but those go without saying…)
This entry was posted
on Friday, July 20th, 2007 at 2:24 pm and is filed under Adaptive Path, Creativity, Design leaders, Experience design, Information Architecture, Interaction Design.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
This post is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
July 20th, 2007 at 3:05 pm
Michael Bierut’s Seventy-nine Short Essays on Design would be my one addition to this list. Nice work, Peter.
July 21st, 2007 at 6:47 pm
Thanks for the list. I’d like to add Thinking with Type by Ellen Lupton.
July 21st, 2007 at 9:21 pm
I will investigate the books on this list which I haven’t yet read. But I’ve never thought that “Cluetrain” came close to standing with the best of the ones I have. I think it is a very neat encapsulation of the bravado and hyperbole of the dot com era. I wrote the following review in 2000 for a company newsletter. While things have progressed to some extent, obviously, I still stand by much of what I wrote.
——
The Cluetrain Manifesto is the latest book to stake a claim as the paradigm-shifting tech bible of the moment. At its best, it’s one of those books that would have made a nifty article. At the other end of the scale, it is representative of the worst kind of high-tech hype, and a microcosm of many of the problems we have in the Web business and in user-centered software design.
Throughout the book, the authors promote a utopian vision of the Web and how it will not only solve all our problems (from consumer to social), but radically transform the way business is done. Some of the ideas are good; but most is common knowledge for anyone working the Web, which is the primary audience for the book. Cluetrain really gets into trouble when it starts making sweeping unsubstantiated claims about everything from users to organizations to politics. The style of the writing is often nothing short of hyperbolic, which makes it very difficult to take seriously. In the first chapter, “Internet Apocalpyse,” Christopher Locke writes,
“Just as GM mistook the Hondas and VWs for a passing fad, most corporations today are totally misreading this invasion from Webspace. Their brand will save them. Right. Their advertising budget will save them. Uh-huh. More bandwidth will save them. Sure. Well … something will save them. They’re just not too sure what it is yet. But the clock is now ticking in Internet time. Maybe they should get a clue. And quick.”
If it weren’t in an Internet book, this kind of writing would simply be dismissed as impudent. What does the author offer to corroborate his claims?
“The Internet has radically changed the nature of the marketplace. I believe this. But how do I presume to know it? Certainly not through market-research reports, most of which aren’t worth the paper they’re written on. I know it because the Internet has changed me and the thousands of people I talk to every week. Maybe the best way to explain this is to tell my own story–talk about who I am and how I got here. Am I representative of the online market? The point is that there is no ‘online market’ in some general abstract sense. More than any market that’s ever existed, the Internet is a collection of unique individuals. I’m one of them.”
So, based on his own experience (rather than worthless research), the author tells us The Truth. There is a massive contradiction here, of course. If the market is so fragmented, how can he and his circle of friends presume to know it from personal experience? This kind of received wisdom is found throughout the book. There isn’t even a bibliography: it’s all anecdotal.
The central idea in the book is that in the wired world, markets are conversations rather than one-way “communications” from producer to consumer. This is an exciting enough idea, but there is no evidence offered to suggest that a wider market, beyond early adopters like the authors of Cluetrain, are participating in the conversation. How does a first-time computer user find out about, for instance, rec.autos.vw? There is certainly no pointer there from http://www.vw.com (which is heavily promoted), and Usenet is chaotic enough even for initiates that there is little hope this hypothetical user will become involved in the kind of online community that provides the platform for a lot of ideas in the book. Conversations should be all-inclusive; they seem currently to be the domain of the online elite.
The online community is also supposed to promote “craft” instead of mass production. But craft is an attribute of the local, not the global; the authors again offer no evidence to support their claim.
“Internet time,” which is taken as a given throughout the book, is one of the most problematic concepts in the Web business. The idea is that things are moving seven times as fast as normal in the Internet business as in everyday life. This is a common way for high tech workers to make themselves feel important. And projects suffer for it: better to launch with severely reduced functionality in three weeks than to step back and look at requirements and provide real value for users (most of whom have never heard of “Internet time”). Web sites are software design and development projects, often very large ones. It’s time we started seeing them as such.
In terms of user-centered design, the book is simply a continuation of the software engineering culture that assumes it knows everything necessary about users. In fact, engineers are not typical users–they never really were–and it has been shown repeatedly that the only way to design usable software is to take steps to understand user needs and involve users in the design process. It cannot be bypassed with assumptions or excuses. We are designing the Web for our users, not for ourselves. Cluetrain is almost entirely inward-looking, taking its cue from Silicon Valley high tech culture. Very engineering-centric. (And very American–including revisionist history and a stab at socialized medicine, from authors who probably don’t realize they live in the only industrialized country without universal access to health care.)
In Chapter 5, “The Hyperlinked Organization,” David Weinberger writes, “Education is the transfer of content into the receptacle that is the student.” This hasn’t been an accepted definition of learning for ages, but it seems to be the model that the authors use exclusively in this book. We credulous readers are supposed to sit back and take it all at face value. But that’s just not the way the Web works.
Thomas Pettzinger, Jr. writes in the foreword that “The Cluetrain Manifesto takes on the arrogance of e-commerce.” Unfortunately, it is simply replaced by a different brand of arrogance. The Web is a wonderful place, but to keep it that way we have to remain vigilant. A conversational online market is not a foregone conclusion.
July 25th, 2007 at 5:57 am
[…] Favourite design-related books from Adaptive Path Blog […]
July 25th, 2007 at 2:02 pm
Thanks for the list. I’ve been meaning to get some more design-related books recently and this gives me a good place to start.